The evolution of notice provisions, from modest procedural devices, to some of the most consequential features of a construction contract, are at odds with the commercial, behavioral, and administrative realities of construction projects, argued Franco Mastrandrea, partner, HKA, in his JCT Povey Lecture, delivered on Tuesday, 17 November 2026.
Franco’s presentation, entitled “Notice Provisions – Has the Drafting Pendulum Swung Too Far?” raised the idea that the increasing formalisation of notice provisions across standard forms of contract, as well as their elevation to statutory obligations in some jurisdictions, has had a transformative effect on projects.
This is particularly important in the context of delays, where notice regimes exert some of their most significant effects.
For the contractor in particular, a single missed notice may determine whether they are able to cover substantial cost, obtain an extension of time, or are denied relief altogether.
Franco highlighted the phenomenon of the contractor’s “double exposure”, whereby they may lose their prolongation cost, whilst at the same time become liable for the employer’s delay damages, even where the employer’s breach is itself the cause of the delay.
Franco argued that there is a disconnect between the rationale for notice provisions and the severe consequences of their breach, and that the same considerations should be made to provide a logical measure of the consequences of non-notification:
“The relevant question is not simply whether notice was omitted, but what difference timely notice would realistically have made. What opportunities were actually lost? What mitigating measures could credibly have been implemented? What financial consequences would likely have followed?”
Franco proposed ideas for more balanced solutions, including reciprocal notification provisions, attenuation of remedies, mandatory consideration of factors such as prejudice, waiver, estoppel and prior knowledge, and – most significantly – the adoption of a counterfactual valuation, grounded in the same objectives used to justify the provisions:
“The most principled solution may be the simplest: to require the party relying upon non-notification to demonstrate what it would actually have done had notice been given, and what financial difference that would realistically have made.”
Following the presentation, Franco took part in an interactive audience Q&A, hosted by JCT chair, Karen Kirkham.
Watch On Demand
The full presentation and Q&A is available to view at: corporate.jctltd.co.uk/povey-lecture-2026.
Visit the web page for more information, including downloadable presentation slides and lecture notes.
About the JCT Povey Lecture
The JCT Povey Lecture is an annual event at which an eminent person is invited to give their thoughts on significant matters that are relevant to the construction and property industry. The purpose of the lecture is to stimulate thought and encourage ways of continuing to improve the quality and value of construction output. The event was inaugurated in 2003 to acknowledge and pay tribute to Philip Povey, who served JCT for fifty years.


